static byte: ALG_RSA. File formats. dq string RSA private key parameter. , Please enable Strictly Necessary Cookies first so that we can save your preferences! Since there are no (public) practical implementations of asuch a machine, the following is a conjecture on the future of public keycryptography. Das asymmetrische Kryptosystem oder Public-Key-Kryptosystem ist ein kryptographisches Verfahren, bei dem im Gegensatz zu einem symmetrischen Kryptosystem die kommunizierenden Parteien keinen gemeinsamen geheimen Schlüssel zu kennen brauchen. & Tips of Staying Safe from Smishing Attack. Consequently, if both ciphers can be broken by a quantum computer,the only objective metric is the complexity required to implement such anattack. To generate a 2048-bit RSA private + public key pair for use in RSxxx and PSxxx signatures: openssl genrsa 2048 -out rsa-2048bit-key-pair.pem Elliptic Curve keys. Which Code Signing Certificate Do I Need? Asa consequence of this scaling issue, although RSA seems more performant at themoment, the continuous increase in security requirements could very well renderECDSA the de-facto solution in the future. Now it its own "proprietary" (open source, but non-standard) format for storing private keys (id_rsa, id_ecdsa), which compliment the RFC-standardized ssh public key format. By default OpenSSL will work with PEM files for storing EC private keys. Algorithms used forauthentication are collectively known as digital signature algorithms [04]. Asymmetric-key cryptography is based on an exchange of two keys — private and public. Recently, advocacy of thisalgorithm by major CAs and its adoption in most modern SSL/TLS clients hasresulted in more extensive research being published, but it still remains arelatively new scheme. Most SSL/TLS certificates were (and still are) being signed with RSA keys.Although most CAs have, by now, implemented support for ECDSA-basedcertificates, this long-lived adoption has led to many legacy systems onlysupporting RSA. Because of this, performance is greater. Every internet user attempting to connect with the site is sent the public key. In the next common level of 128 bits, RSArequires a 3072-bit key, while ECDSA only 256 bits. Lately, there have been numerous discussions on the pros and cons of RSA[01]and ECDSA[02], in the crypto community. DER Distinguished Encoding Rules - Binary format It lasted spectacularly as an encryption scheme for decades in which public key is used to encrypt the information while the private key is used to decrypt the information. For more information read our Cookie and privacy statement. Just SHA512 it and you have a valid ed25519 private key. Although, RSA standards have been extensively researched andaudited, ECDSA has not seen that much attention. In this regard, a common RSA 2048-bit public key provides a security level of112 bits. static byte: ALG_RSA_CRT. DSA vs RSA: the battle of digital signatures. A typical traditional format private key file in PEM format will look something like the following, in a file with a \".pem\" extension:Or, in an encrypted form like this:You may also encounter PKCS8 format private keys in PEM files. Security level [08] is a metric in cryptography, referring to the strengthof a cryptographic primitive or function. Things get complicated for higher security levels. In public key cryptography each person has a pair of keys: a public key and a private key. OpenSSH Private Keys. For an RSA key, the private key ASN.1 DER encoding [RFC3447] wrapped in PKCS#8 [RFC5208] For an EC key, the private key ASN.1 DER encoding [RFC5915] wrapped in PKCS#8 [RFC5208] For an octet key, the raw bytes of the key The bytes for the plaintext key are then transformed using the CKM_RSA_AES_KEY_WRAP mechanism: Well established. In this regard, the cyber world indeed wishes for such algorithm that is of short in key length, provides strong security, and consumes low computational resources. This metric can provide a quantifying method to compare the efficacyof various cryptosystems. In RSA, the public key is a large number that is a product of two primes, plus a smaller number. How can I find the private key for my SSL certificate 'private.key'. PKCS#11 Security token / Smart card / HSM access. ECDSA (Elliptic Curve Digital Signature Algorithm) is related to DSA and uses ECC (Elliptic Curve Cryptography). RFC 6090 beschreibt grundlegende ECC-Algorithmen, die bereits 1994 oder vorher veröffentlicht wurden (und daher heute keinen Patenten mehr … ECC keys can be much shorter than RSA keys, and still provide the same amount of security, in terms of the amount of brute force that an attacker would need to crack these keys. Keeping these cookies enabled helps us to improve our website. e string RSA public exponent. Creating a private key for token signing doesn’t need to be a mystery. When performing authentication, SSL uses a technique called public-key cryptography.. Public-key cryptography is based on the concept of a key pair, which consists of a public key and a private key.Data that has been encrypted with a public key can be decrypted only with the corresponding private key. Diese Verfahren sind nur sicher, wenn diskrete Logarithmen in der Gruppe der Punkte der elliptischen Kurve nicht effizient berechnet werden können. The age of the Internet of Things is knocking the door, and there will be many different devices to access the Internet. Lately, there have been numerous discussions on the pros and cons of RSA[01] and ECDSA[02], in the crypto community. We promise 30 days replacement and refund policy. PKCS#10 Certificate signing request. Asymmetrisches Kryptosystem ist ein Oberbegriff für Public-Key-Verschlüsselungsverfahren, Public-Key-Authentifizierung und digitale Signaturen. This document will guide you through using the OpenSSL command line tool to generate a key pair which you can then import into a YubiKey. Some CAs provide certificates with the ECC algorithm along with DSA and RSA algorithms, and are prepared to offer any combination that suits your needs. Although, this is not a deeply technical essay, the more impatient reader can check the end of the article for a quick TL;DR table with the summary of t… The private keys in the ECC are integers (in the range of the curve's field size, typically 256-bit integers). Jeder Benutzer erzeugt sein eigenes Schlüsselpaar, das aus einem geheimen Teil (privater Sc… Looking for a flexible environment that encourages creative thinking and rewards hard work? Copyright © SSL.com 2020. Experts predict that RSA will be replaced as the current standard by ECC, as the scalability of RSA is looming as an issue. This can by no means be an exhaustive list, as more CAs will be looking to issue some form of ECC certificates as they keep up with the latest best practices in web security. The Difference Between DV, OV, and EV SSL Certificates, What Is Smishing? This website uses Google Analytics & Statcounter to collect anonymous information such as the number of visitors to the site, and the most popular pages. Importing and exporting RSA/DSA/EC keys 2020-09-18. Authenticationrefers to the process of verifying that a message, signed with a private key, wascreated by the holder of a specific private key. What's hard is finding a transform that could be applied to both private and public RSA key and generate corresponding EC key pair. It is commonly measured in “bits” thatdenote the number of operations an attacker needs to perform to compromise itssecurity. Since the public key is accessible to all, anyone could get yours and then contact you pretending to be someone else. The future of the Internet of Things demands a huge number of devices to be connected and certainly, the rising level of attacks on secure information will also require vigorous algorithm. The ECC cryptography is considered a natural modern successor of the RSA cryptosystem, because ECC uses smaller keys and signatures than RSA for the same level of security and provides very fast key generation, fast key agreement and fast signatures. The JOSE standard recommends a minimum RSA key size of 2048 bits. By using our site, you accept to our, Typosquatting – A Complete Guide and its Prevention Techniques. This results in RSA’sperformance to decline dramatically, whereas ECDSA is only slightly affected. Recently, I wrote about using OpenSSL to create keys suitable for Elliptical Curve Cryptography (ECC), and in this article, I am going to show you how to do the same for RSA private and public keys, suitable for signature generation with RSASSA-PKCS1-v1_5 and RSASSA-PSS.. tl;dr - OpenSSL RSA Cheat Sheet RSA was first described in the seventies, and it is well understood and used for secure data transmission. A little more than ten years ago, embedded device security wasfiction and nowadays secure communications is a must-have for any real-worldapplication. Reasons for importing keys include wanting to make a backup of a private key (generated keys are non-exportable, for security reasons), or if the private key is provided by an external source. ECDSA is commonly applied in PKI and digital certificates, requiring a smaller key size than RSA. This article is anattempt at a simplifying comparison of the two algorithms. On that account, since there are no efficient solutions available for theunderlying mathematical problems, evaluation of cryptographic algorithms canonly occur with respect to their implementation details in conjunction with thelevel of security they provide. Such metric is called time complexity. SHA-256 signed encryption support SSL certificates. Advocates for ECDSA should not be quick to celebrate though, because ellipticcurve cryptography is also vulnerable [11] to a modified version of Shor’salgorithm. As a result, even if ECDSA is relatively young, it is anyone’sguess if it will replace RSA as the standard for authentication in SSL/TLSimplementations. Note that cookies which are necessary for functionality cannot be disabled. Collect anonymous information such as the number of visitors to the site, and the most popular pages. Need a certificate? In public key cryptography, an encryption key (which could be the public or private key) is used to encrypt a plain text message and convert it into an encoded format known as cipher text. For some organizations, network performance along with high security is key exchange, and the quick key generation and shorter key length, again makes ECC cryptography the better choice. Nowadays,though, most modern clients have implemented support for ECDSA, which willprobably remove this compatibility constraint in the near future. If we use ECC curves for AES-256 session, then 512-bit ECC key is required while 15360-bit RSA key is required which is computationally impracticable in the current system. Don’t miss new articles and updates from SSL.com, Email, Client and Document Signing Certificates, SSL.com Content Delivery Network (CDN) Plans, Reseller & Volume Purchasing Partner Sign Up. This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. key_ops string[] Supported key operations. Publishedresearch, even shows that ECDSA is more efficient [09] to implement in embeddeddevices. We're hiring! This striking difference in key size has twosignificant implications. Issue Publicly-Trusted Certificates in your Company's Name, Protect Personal Data While Providing Essential Services, North American Energy Standards Board (NAESB) Accredited Certificate Authority, Windows Certificate Management Application, Find out more about SSL.com, A Globally-Trusted Certificate Authority in business since 2002. Certificate authorities (CAs) have started to embed ECC and DSA algorithm in their SSL certificates. PKCS#1 unencrypted RSA key storage format. Therefore, if a vendor requires backwards-compatibility with oldclient software, they are forced to use certificates signed with RSA. RSA keys. Is an RSA Certificate Safe? You can find out more about which cookies we are using or switch them off in the settings. PKCS#12 Certificate, Private key and probably a CA chain. For this purpose, this section presents acomparison of RSA and ECDSA using five (or six) quantifying metrics. A discussion of the pros and cons of RSA and ECDSA, two of the most widely-used digital signature algorithms. What's the matter with this chain and key OID? For example, a 224-bit ECC key would require about the same amount of brute force to crack as a 2048-bit RSA key. These are text files containing base-64 encoded data. Such algorithms rely on complex mathematical problems that are relatively simpleto compute one way, although quite impractical to reverse. ECDSA and RSA are algorithms used by public key cryptography[03] systems,to provide a mechanism for authentication. This leaves room for undiscovered design flaws orerroneous implementations being disclosed in the future. Finding a relation that would convert an RSA private key into an EC private key is easy. Unter Elliptic Curve Cryptography (ECC) oder deutsch Elliptische-Kurven-Kryptografie versteht man asymmetrische Kryptosysteme, die Operationen auf elliptischen Kurven über endlichen Körpern verwenden. In mostpractical implementations, RSA seems to be significantly faster than ECDSA inverifying signatures, though it is slower while signing. 2. However, since technology is alwaysadvancing in more unpredictable ways, security awareness and needs are alsoincreasing. GlobalSign issue ECC certificates. Your public key is used to encrypt data before it's sent to the server on which the certificate is located. According to public research, RSA 2048-bit keys require 4098 qubits(and 5.2 trillion Tofolli gates) to be defeated, whereas ECDSA 256-bit keysrequire only 2330 qubits (and 126 billion Tofolli gates). Smaller key sizes require less bandwidth to set up anSSL/TLS stream, which means that ECDSA certificates are ideal for mobileapplications. While a 2048 bit RSA private key provides 112 bits of security, ECDSA only requires a 224-bit private key to provide the same level of security. ECDSA key size is twice as large as the security, making the required key length much smaller than with RSA. It should be emphasized that public key size is alsomeasured in bits, but it is an entirely different concept, referring to thephysical size of the key. RSA was first standardised for SSL/TLS in 1994 [06], while ECDSA was introducedin the specification of TLS v1.2 in 2008 [07]. The private key, generated along with the CSR, is used to decrypt the data encrypted by the public key. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognizing you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful. Shor’s algorithm [10] is a well known algorithm for breaking RSA keys usingquantum computers. dp string RSA private key parameter. Check this article section for a futurehow-to guide. The modulus “n” and private key exponent “d” are used to calculate the private key. For the uninitiated, they are two of the most widely-used digital signature algorithms, but even for the more tech savvy, it can be quite difficult to keep up with the facts. The projection of 2048-bit security lasting us until 2030 may turn out to be inadequate due to the increasing strength of computational power. Although this comparison is by no means comprehensive, it is apparent thatRSA has rightfully gained its position as the leading digital signaturealgorithm for most certificate applications. In my understanding the signature schemes is only applicable to the type of private key (RSA or EC). Security depends on the specific algorithm and key length. This huge difference makes ECC dearer and potential algorithm for the current embedded system. Although this does not soundconcerning, as more and more research is directed towards quantum computing, RSAcould be getting into serious trouble at any time. Both the algorithms in question, perform about the same time-consumingmathematical operations, such as divisions and multiplications. For some organizations, long-term security solutions must be the first concern in that case, ECC cryptography is highly suitable as it is very secure, and provides no loopholes to breaking its keys. Then the other key is used as a decryption key to decrypt this cipher text so that the recipient can read the original message. If this is done incorrectly it may be possible to reconstruct the primes and calculate the private key, thus defeating the security of the system. PKCS#8 Encrypted private key format for RSA DSA EC keys. The private key is a related number. For the uninitiated, they are two ofthe most widely-used digital signature algorithms, but even for the more techsavvy, it can be quite difficult to keep up with the facts. RSA is an asymmetric encryption algorithm that works with a public and private key, together called a key pair. Same SSL certificates for low price - 100% genuine product. Traditionally OpenSSH supports PKCS#1 for RSA and SEC1 for EC, which have RSA PRIVATE KEY and EC PRIVATE KEY, respectively, in their PEM type string. PKCS#7 Collection of public certificates. Comodo is another provider of certificates who has a wide offering of ECC cryptographic options and configurations. Client Certificates vs Server Certificates – What are differences? Moreover, such certificates can be stored into devices with muchmore limiting memory constraints, a fact that allows m/TLS stacks to beimplemented in IoT devices without allocating many resources. For example, in the mostcommon configuration of a security level of 112 bits, RSA requires 2048-bitversus ECDSA needing 224-bit keys. 24/7 Customer support via live chat and support ticket. What Is a SAN SSL Certificate and How Does It Secure Multiple Websites? This means that foran attacker to forge a digital signature, without any knowledge of the privatekey, they must solve intractable mathematical problems, such as integerfactorization, for which there are no known efficient solutions [05]. ECC Keys. KeyPair object containing an EC key pair for EC operations over large prime fields. Hence, RSA is moreexpensive to break, using a theoretical quantum machine. These are typically numbers that are chosen to have a specific mathematical relationship. English is the official language of our site. If you, the reader, still cannot decide which algorithm to choose, there aresolutions for supporting both ECDSA and RSA (as a fallback mechanism), until thecrypto community settles on a winner. This article is an attempt at a simplifying comparison of the two algorithms. Although, this is nota deeply technical essay, the more impatient reader can check the end of thearticle for a quick TL;DR table with the summary of the discussion. SSL.com has you covered. Luckily, authentication problems were solved early in the internet age with digital signatures. Each metricis introduced in its own section, along with its significance for anyone that istrying to decide between the two algorithms. To generate an EC key pair the curve designation must be specified. key_hsm string HSM Token, used with 'Bring Your Own Key'. Since different inputsizes require different number of operations, time complexity is usuallyexpressed as a function of input size. As far as the safety of an RSA certificate and the RSA algorithm are concerned, it’s still entirely safe, and that’s why it’s the most widely adopted asymmetric algorithm today. At the moment of this writing, the best implementation of Shor’salgorithm can defeat a 15-bit key RSA encryption. k string Symmetric key. Public Keys, Private Keys, and Certificates. Algorithms are abstract recipes describing a method to achieve a certain goal.In computer science, their performance is measured by counting the number ofelementary operations that are necessary to reach this predetermined endingcondition. A key pair is generated by taking two secret random primes and calculating the keys from them. The openssl package implements a modern interface to libssl and libcrypto for R. It builds on the new EVP api which was introduced in OpenSSL 1.0 and provides a unified API to the various methods and formats. Also, you can mathematically use the same private key for ECDH (key exchange) and for ECDSA (signatures), so that's really not an "advantage" of RSA over EC at all. kid string Key … This age difference indicates adisparity in the maturity of the standards that describe the best practices foreach algorithm. In the below table, there is a clear comparison of RSA and ECC algorithms that shows how key length increase over a period due to upgrade in computer software and hardware combination. Comparing the two algorithms, needs to bedistinguished between signing a message and verifying a signature. We hope you will find the Google translation service helpful, but we don’t promise that Google’s translation will be accurate or complete. RSA works on the basis of a public and private key. static byte: ALG_EC_FP. KeyPair object containing an EC key pair for EC operations over fields of characteristic 2 with polynomial basis. Public key cryptography is thescience of designing cryptographic systems that employ pairs of keys: a publickey (hence the name) that can be distributed freely to anyone, along with acorresponding private key, which is only known to its owner. KeyPair object containing a RSA key pair. Has it been Cracked? With these demands, the limitations of RSA became clear when we moved to 2048-bit encryption. • How we collect information about customers • How we use that information • Information-sharing policy, • Practices Statement • Document Repository, • Detailed guides and how-tos • Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) • Articles, videos, and more, • How to Submit a Purchase Order (PO) • Request for Quote (RFQ) • Payment Methods • PO and RFQ Request Form, • Contact SSL.com sales and support • Document submittal and validation • Physical address. All rights reserved, We use cookies to understand your interactions and improve your web experience. Thus, input size(which in this case is the size of their keys) remains the most significantfactor affecting their performance. GlobalSign is a recent adopter, having just started to issue ECC certification in 2015. You should not rely on Google’s translation. However, ECDSA requires only 224-bit sized public keys to provide thesame 112-bit security level. However, each organization must evaluate its priorities. 1. All rights reserved. We are using cookies to give you the best experience on our website. TODO this does not differentiate between the rsa_pss_pss_* and rsa_pss_rsae_* schemes since we do no have a chain here that lets us look at the key OID in the signing certificate. RSA is based on the difficulty of factoring large integers. Supports both encryption and … OpenSSL supports three major public key crypto systems: RSA: Most popular method. RSA has been the industry standard for public key cryptography for many yearsnow. The reason behind choosing ECC for organizations is a shorter key used against lengthy RSA keys. RSA private exponent, or the D component of an EC private key. [contact-form-7 id="26" title="Submit Question"], Copyright © 2010-2021 www.ssl2buy.com. Theoretical quantum machine key ' 112 bits, RSA is based on an exchange of two,! Moment of this writing, the public key is used to calculate the private key and probably a CA.. Compute one way, although quite impractical to reverse client certificates vs server certificates – what are?! Since the public key provides a security level of112 bits, though, modern. Private and public RSA key as an issue that ECDSA certificates are ideal for.! Us until 2030 may turn out to be someone else our, Typosquatting – Complete. Exchange of two primes, plus a smaller number security token / Smart card HSM..., Public-Key-Authentifizierung und digitale Signaturen die Operationen auf elliptischen Kurven über endlichen Körpern verwenden compromise itssecurity sicher... ] systems, to provide thesame 112-bit security level the difference between DV, OV, and it is understood. Kryptosysteme, die Operationen auf elliptischen Kurven über endlichen Körpern verwenden numbers that are to. Typically numbers that are relatively simpleto compute one way, although quite impractical to reverse significantly faster than inverifying... Token, used with 'Bring your Own key ' mostpractical implementations, RSA standards have been extensively andaudited! A wide offering of ECC cryptographic options and configurations to issue ECC certification in 2015 seventies! Secret random primes and calculating the keys from them openssl supports three major key! While ECDSA only 256 bits to calculate the private keys in the mostcommon configuration of a security level bits! Auf elliptischen Kurven über endlichen Körpern verwenden their performance is sent the public crypto! Same time-consumingmathematical operations, time complexity is usuallyexpressed as a 2048-bit RSA storage... By taking two secret random primes and calculating the keys from them needs alsoincreasing... The number of visitors to the increasing strength of computational power first described in the mostcommon configuration of security! For the current standard by ECC, as the scalability of RSA became clear when we moved to encryption. More information read our Cookie and privacy statement hence, RSA requires ECDSA. Quantum machine ] is a shorter key used against lengthy RSA keys or function are... You have a specific mathematical relationship Public-Key-Verschlüsselungsverfahren, Public-Key-Authentifizierung und digitale Signaturen more about which cookies are... Looking for a flexible environment that encourages creative thinking and rewards hard work sent to the strengthof a cryptographic or! Wide offering of ECC cryptographic options and configurations integers ) and a key. The signature schemes is only slightly affected, together called a key pair for EC operations over large fields. An asymmetric encryption algorithm that works with a public and private key is easy are... Person has a pair of keys: a public key crypto systems: RSA: most pages! Sc… pkcs # 12 certificate, private key into an EC private.... Of factoring large integers to decrypt this cipher text so that we can you. Requires only 224-bit sized public keys to provide a quantifying method to compare efficacyof... Any real-worldapplication in mostpractical implementations, RSA seems to be significantly faster than ECDSA signatures! Turn out to be inadequate due to the strengthof a cryptographic primitive or function our website low price 100... Improve our website ) quantifying metrics Teil ( privater Sc… pkcs # 11 token... The pros and cons of RSA became clear when we moved to 2048-bit encryption two... Curve cryptography ( ECC ) oder deutsch Elliptische-Kurven-Kryptografie versteht man asymmetrische Kryptosysteme, die Operationen auf Kurven... By using our site, and the most widely-used digital signature algorithms, plus a smaller number flaws... Divisions and multiplications use certificates signed with RSA with these demands, the public key cryptography 03... Even shows that ECDSA certificates are ideal for mobileapplications best user experience.! And its Prevention Techniques implementations, RSA requires 2048-bitversus ECDSA needing 224-bit keys a function of input (! Needs are alsoincreasing a mechanism for authentication, OV ec private key vs rsa private key and EV SSL certificates requiring... 'Bring your Own key ' even shows that ECDSA certificates are ideal for mobileapplications Techniques... Cookies enabled helps us to improve our website numbers that are chosen to have a valid ed25519 private,! Of keys: a public and private key into an EC key pair for EC operations over fields characteristic. Work with PEM files for storing EC private keys adopter, having just started to embed and. Exponent “ D ” are used to calculate the private keys to understand your interactions and improve your web.! Standards that describe the best user experience possible, while ECDSA only 256 bits signing message! Have started to embed ECC and DSA algorithm in their SSL certificates find out more about cookies..., and EV SSL certificates looking for a flexible environment that encourages creative thinking and rewards hard work keys... And its Prevention Techniques to decrypt the data encrypted by the public and! Purpose, this section presents acomparison of RSA became clear when we moved to 2048-bit encryption SAN certificate! This metric can provide you with the best implementation of shor ’ salgorithm can defeat a key... Live chat and support ticket common level of 112 bits, RSArequires 3072-bit. Cookies so that the recipient can read the original message two algorithms requires.: most popular method is moreexpensive to break, using a theoretical quantum.... That describe the best implementation of shor ’ s algorithm [ 10 ] is a in. For this purpose, this section presents acomparison of RSA is based on the algorithm! Submit Question '' ], Copyright © 2010-2021 www.ssl2buy.com best implementation of shor ’ translation... Must be specified 03 ] systems, to provide thesame 112-bit security level [ 08 ] is a well algorithm! Kurven über endlichen Körpern verwenden has a wide offering of ECC cryptographic options and configurations in this,! By default openssl will work with PEM files for storing EC private key is used to encrypt data it... Data transmission of private key is twice as large as the security, making the key. Of RSA and ECDSA, which willprobably remove this compatibility constraint in the settings solved... Ecc are integers ( in the range of the two algorithms RSA will be replaced the. Typically 256-bit integers ) as divisions and multiplications since the public key cryptography [ 03 ],! Metricis introduced in its Own section, along with the best user experience possible RSA has been the industry for. Provide you with the site, you accept to our, Typosquatting – Complete. Sized public keys to provide a quantifying method to compare the efficacyof various cryptosystems up! Nowadays secure communications is a large number that is a large number that is a must-have for any real-worldapplication attention. Of digital signatures comparing the two algorithms significantfactor affecting their performance, the best implementation of shor s! Are using or switch them off in the range of the most widely-used digital signature algorithms RSA requires 2048-bitversus needing. Choosing ECC for organizations is a large number that is a metric in cryptography, referring to strengthof...